The Easiest and Simplest Way to Can Tomatoes

Published: Mar 21, 2020 · Modified: Jun 12, 2023 by Aimee Burmester · This post may contain affiliate links · 31 Comments

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Canning tomatoes is a great way to preserve summer's bounty and enjoy your garden flavors into the winter. Use this basic canned tomato recipe as a foundation for all your canned tomato variations!

Why Use this Tomato Canning Method

If you've ever canned tomatoes before, you know the process has quite a few steps. While those steps are not hard, they can take quite a bit of time and require a lot of clean-up.

Peeling tomato skins by scoring them, then boiling, then quickly moving them to ice water before you actually peel them is just too many steps for me. Also, burning my fingers time and again is not my favorite pastime.

I learned the oven-peeling method over a decade ago and I have been simplifying my tomato canning process since. I encourage you to try this method as well!

The Easiest and Simplest Way to Can Tomatoes, Simple Tomato Canning, Tomato Canning Tips, Canning

Ingredients in Canned Tomatoes

Tomatoes: To start, you need tomatoes. I will be honest, I have used a couple different types of tomato. I have used Big Boys and Romas and San Marzanos, and I definitely choose San Marzanos over any other type, but Romas are just as good and easier to come by. They also grow easier in the Midwest.

Seasonings: Because this is a basic tomato recipe, I like to keep the seasonings relatively tame. I encourage you to experiment with different seasonings that fit your taste. You can make this recipe more italian based or more latin tasting by switching up what herbs you use. Here's what I used in this base:

Garlic Powder or Minced Garlic
AlpineTouch I have had quite a few people ask what Alpine seasoning is, and its a basic salt blend that includes many seasonings in one. Made in Montana, I love supporting small businesses like this one!
Bay Leaves
Olive Oil
Balsamic Vinegar
Onion Powder
Paprika
Salt & Pepper

Comparing other types of tomatoes for canning

Big Boys, also called fat boys, grow really well in the Midwest, however, they have more water in them compared to San Marzanos and Romas. San Marzanos and Romas are meaty, very few seeds, and not much water.

Big Boy might not matter much now as you’re reading, but later, when you try your hand at canning you’ll understand why I choose a meatier tomato. A tomato with less water takes less time to cook down and you don’t have as much “shrinkage,” in your final product.

How to Can Tomatoes Quickly and Easily

Since I started canning years ago, I’ve learned a few tricks and tips, and I want to share with you now the quickest, easiest, and laziest way to can tomatoes. This is the method I use to can tomatoes with little effort and as little mess as possible.

The easiest and simplest way to can tomatoes

Step One: Prep Your Tomatoes & Preheat your oven

I preheat my oven to 350 degrees, and then take the stems off all the tomatoes and rinse them.

Once rinsed, I halve all the tomatoes and place them cut side down on my aluminum foil-lined sheet pan. I drizzle olive oil, balsamic vinegar, garlic powder, and onion powder over all the tomatoes.

Step Two: Bake your tomatoes & Peel the Skins

This is the sheet pan I like to use for baking. They are thick and sturdy and can fit a ton of tomatoes on them. I have two of them so that when I’m canning a large batch of tomatoes, I can always have one in the oven so I can speed up my process.

Bake the tomatoes for about 40 minutes, then let cool about the same time. Cooking them in the oven begins the cooking process and helps the skin detach itself from the rest of the tomato. You will see the skins start to peel back and crack. That’s exactly what we want.

Let the tomatoes cool. Once cooled, simply pull the skins off the meat. You have literally removed all the tomato skins without a single water bath. SO. EASY.

Step Three: Heat Jars in the Oven

Another time and mess eliminating step is heating your jars up in the oven. I first run them through my dishwasher on the high heat, sanitize cycle, then I move them over to the oven that I have turned down to 200 degrees.

Step Three: Cook down your sauce

After the skins are removed, I place all my tomatoes in my favorite pot, my enameled cast iron dutch oven, aka the Black Mamba of my kitchen. I use it to cook EVERYTHING. Just yesterday I used it to bake bread, brown some ground beef and make this sauce. It’s so freaking versatile.

I add Alpine Touch, garlic powder, onion powder, paprika, salt, pepper, and allow them to cook some of the water out. I don’t measure any of those things; I probably should.

I break up my tomatoes while they cook with this mix and chop tool. While most people use a mix and chop tool to break up ground meats, it actually helps to break up the tomatoes with it as well because it speeds the cooking process along by breaking down the tomatoes quicker.

Step Four: Add Tomatoes to Jars

Once everything is hot, and the tomatoes have cooked down to my desired “doneness,” I scoop them into the hot jars. I use Ball pint size jars for this recipe, and while I didn’t have any on hand this day, I prefer using the wide mouth jars because it is easier to scoop my sauce into.

Normally, I will also use this canning kit from Ball, but because I was just doing a small batch, I didn't get out all my canning supplies. I definitely recommend this kit, however, because it has all the tools you need to move your food to jars the quickest and cleanest way.

If you're looking for a list of essential canning supplies, check out this post: The Essential Canning Checklist to Get Started Canning

I add a bay leaf to each jar (don’t forget to take the bay leaf out later when you go to eat the ‘maters), and I leave at least a quarter inch of space in the top of each jar, wipe off the rim, then place the lid on, and twist on the ring.

Step Five: Water Bath Your Jars & Seal

After my jars are filled, I add them to my large Waterbath Canning Pot, fill with water so the water covers just over the lids, and heat the water to almost boiling--about 10-15 minutes.

The best part of canning? Hearing the “pop” when the lids seal. Such satisfaction!

I keep my jars of tomatoes for two years usually, and use them for everything: tomato sauce, additions to soups and stews, pizza sauce, chili base, anything that needs tomatoes.

Tools I use to Can Tomatoes

The investment in each batch of canned tomatoes is very minimal. There are some upfront costs to canning, but after purchasing the supplies initially, I’ve been able to use them over and over again. Here’s a list of the supplies I use nearly every time I can:

Hope you enjoy!

Are you looking for other canning recipes? Check out these posts:

📖 Recipe

Print Pin

5 from 4 votes

Canned Tomatoes

Here is a basic recipe for canning tomatoes with very little mess

Cuisine American

Keyword canned tomatoes, canning tomatoes, tomato sauce

Prep Time 1

Cook Time 45

Equipment

Cookie Sheet
Dutch Oven
Wide Mouth Mason Jars with Metal Rings and Seals
Canning Equipment

Ingredients

20 Lbs Tomatoes makes between 7 and 8 pints
Garlic Powder or Minced Garlic
Alpine Seasoning
Bay Leaves
Olive Oil
Balsamic Vinegar
Onion Powder
Paprika
Salt & Pepper

Instructions

Preheat oven to 350 degrees, wash and sanitize all jars, and then take the stems off all the tomatoes and rinse them.
Halve all the tomatoes and place them cut-side down on an aluminum foil-lined sheet pan. Drizzle olive oil, balsamic vinegar, garlic powder, and onion powder over all the tomatoes.
Bake the tomatoes for about 40 minutes, then let cool about the same time. Cooking them in the oven begins the cooking process and helps the skin detach itself from the rest of the tomato. You will see the skins start to peel back and crack which is perfect.
Turn oven down to 200 degrees, then place jars (just jars), in the oven to keep warm.
Let the tomatoes cool. Once cooled, simply pull the skins off the meat.
After the skins are removed, place tomatoes (in batches) in dutch oven. Add Alpine Touch and more garlic powder, and onion powder.
Allow tomatoes to cook down 10-20 minutes. At the same time, boil lids and metal rings from mason jars.
Once everything is hot, and the tomatoes have cooked down to my desired “doneness,” remove jars from oven one at a time and scoop tomatoes into the hot jars.
Add a bay leaf to each jar, and leave at least a quarter inch of space in the top of each jar, wipe off the rim, then place the lid on,and twist on the ring.
Fill waterbath pot with water, add in jars, and heat water to almost boiling. About 10-15 minutes.